Apr 13 2010
The Cyclemeter Review
You may remember I started using Cyclemeter (Abvio, $4.99) about a month ago. I’d used a few other tracking apps in the past, and when I decided that Fitnio had failed me for the last time, I plunked down the $4.99 for what looked like the best cycling app out there.
Initial impressions were great. Cyclemeter is packed with nice features. In fact, I can’t think of much that’s missing (Strava support would be really cool, but I’ll get into why it’s not on my features wishlist in a minute). It seems to be geared toward the kind of user who wants as much info in as many ways as possible, which to me is always a good thing in this kind of app. Not only can I tweet my rides for everyone on Facebook to see, but they can follow along as I ride. Useful for coworkers who might start to wonder how much later I’ll be getting in to work – They can actually check the map to see where I am. Not that anyone does, as far as I know. I also have a ride report emailed to me when I finish, and have a folder in my Gmail just for recorded rides. Pretty cool.
There are, however, some drawbacks. For one, the GPS is not as accurate as in a dedicated device. Riding with a bunch of engineers, some of whom work on mobile devices, I’ve gathered that this is a weakness in all GPS-enabled phones. The GPS unit just isn’t as robust as in something like a Garmin, so phones use cell towers to assist in finding their position. This becomes a major weakness when you have a bad signal, which is especially a problem with the iPhone in San Francisco. Most of the time it’s close enough, but occasionally it’ll lose track of a significant portion of a ride and end up drawing a straight line between points where it had a good signal. That’s fine, if you’re going in a straight line the whole time. Less fine if GPS cuts out for a longer period and misses an important turn or two (see some of Dad’s rides for an example). This is why Strava support isn’t a realistic thing to hope for. Apparently the Strava team has been working on iPhone support for some time, but the accuracy just isn’t there. Having a bike mount for my phone has alleviated some of the GPS problems, compared to when I rode with my phone in my pocket.
I had a lot of problems when I had my corporate email synced with my phone. For security reasons, the phone had to lock itself automatically and require a password to unlock. Turning this off was not an option, and it is not easy to put in a password on a phone while riding. It would have been OK if Cyclemeter could function while the screen was locked, but I never had any real success getting that to work. It’s been working fine since I unsynced my mail.
Maybe the worst thing about the app is that it can be SLOW. Yesterday when I finished my ride, it took about two minutes to “end” the ride and maybe two more to upload it. That’s a long time to stand there holding your phone when there’s bacon and pancakes waiting for you. It’s also a problem when starting after having paused the ride, which is OK if you’re riding alone but less OK if your group decides to leave the water stop suddenly. I don’t know if the iPhone 3GS, being a faster phone, has this problem or not. Maybe when I upgrade to whatever awesome new iPhone comes out next it’ll go away.
Drawbacks and caveats aside, this is still a very cool app and has become my go-to ride tracker. It has a great display screen, easy to read while on the bike:
Battery life seems to be better than on competing apps. (Note that I took the screenshot above after charging my phone, so the 78% after that ride is not accurate.) When I rode Skyline earlier this week, I finished in 3:18:41 and had 15% battery power left. Impressive, especially since the screen and wi-fi were on the entire time. It saves your routes, which makes it really easy to keep track of how this week’s ride compares to last week’s.
The Map feature is nice, not only can you use it mid-ride if you get lost, but it stores rides so you can show off later. I went to a bar last weekend and was showing my friends what this Cyclemeter stuff I’ve been spamming all over Facebook is about. On showing them the map, the common reaction was “You did THAT on a BIKE?”
It also has a nice graphing feature if you want to really geek out about stats. I don’t use this much at all, but it’s still pretty cool.
I’ve found it also works well for tracking runs. I’m not crazy about taking my iPhone running with me, but I’m also not about to go spend a couple hundred dollars on a Garmin watch for the dozen or so miles I run each month. Again, it’s comparable in performance to other apps that I’ve used. Abvio also makes Runmeter and Walkmeter, but I haven’t tried them out since Cyclemeter does everything. I suspect they’re functionally identical and the real deciding factor is which logo you like best.
One more thing to wrap up the review. Dad and I have both been using Cyclemeter to track our rides for a few weeks, and we’ve both had our share of problems. The guys at Abvio have been great about responding to tweets through @Cyclemeter when we’ve had issues. Most of the problems stemmed from inherent weaknesses in the iPhone’s GPS or from having my corporate email synced to the phone, we never took advantage of their tech support, but the fact that they were prompt and willing to help really says a lot about them. I’d definitely buy another Abvio app.
3 responses so far
Very fine review and very accurate. I second what Colin says. I think knowing how the GPS works on an iPhone was pretty good for guy with an English degree – I’m sure not an engineer at an elite Silicon Valley firm working on mobile devices. It’s nice to have Colin’s professional colleagues affirm my suspicions, though. I have a 3Gs iPhone and don’t experience the slowness issues Colin writes about. There are some absolute accuracy issues, but that has to be attributed to cell signal and how the network interacts with the mobile device. For instance, my top speed today was not 64 mph! I’ll post my ride from today.
Also, I sometimes play an iTunes list while riding (like today). Cyclemeter worked well, although a 3 hour ride, with tunes, with GPS, etc ran through quite a bit of battery. It did not deplete the battery entirely though. I generally turn off the screen on Cyclemeter because I carry in my back jersey pocket.
Good app. Good responsiveness from Abvio guys. Still glad I have my iSport power meter to give me lots of the stats I need.
Reply
“Having a bike mount for my phone has alleviated some of the GPS problems, compared to when I rode with my phone in my pocket.” – what bike mount did you buy or recommend? Thanks!
Reply
I have had problems with Cyclemeter in the last two weeks.
It struggles to get a GPS fix on a route that worked OK previously.
I start it off, pop it in to my arm band and push off. But when I get to work, it still says Zero distance.
Is it a problem since the last update?
Reply